Crispy Stuffing Bites

Name: Crispy Stuffing Bites
Prep time: 20 min
Cook time: 25 min
Ingredients: 12 cups White or sourdough bread cubes (completely dried and staled); 1 cup Unsalted butter; 1 cup Celery (finely diced); 1 cup Yellow onion (finely diced); ½ cup Fresh flat-leaf parsley (finely chopped); 2 tbsp. Fresh sage (chopped); 1 tbsp. Fresh thyme (leaves stripped and chopped); 1 tsp. Kosher salt; ½ tsp. Freshly ground black pepper; ¾ cup Low-sodium chicken broth; 3 Large eggs (room temperature)

Jump to recipe
August 10, 2026

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read the disclosure policy.

Okay so here’s the thing about stuffing. My grandmother made it every Thanksgiving in this big casserole dish, and nobody touched it until she cut it into squares and plopped them on everybody’s plate. It was fine, I liked it. My kids, though? They won’t eat stuffing like that. Something about the texture, I don’t know. They want finger food.

Two years ago, day after Thanksgiving, I had so much leftover stuffing sitting in my fridge and zero ideas. My neighbor Pam said roll it into balls and throw them in the oven. I thought she was joking. She was not.

I love leftover stuffing. Especially if I also have leftover giblet gravy. I can eat it for days. Or as long as it stays fresh. But I was running out of ideas.

The outside gets this crunchy golden shell and the middle stays warm and soft. My daughter put away nine of them that first time. Nine. Then asked if we could do Thanksgiving again tomorrow. I said no but made another batch on Sunday anyway.

They’re a fall staple now. I bring them to potlucks and the plate comes back empty every time. My sister-in-law tried taking credit for them at a church dinner once, which. Bold move, Karen.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

These crispy stuffing balls are the kind of food that makes people crowd around a table, and the amount of work that goes into them is almost embarrassing.

Perfect Thanksgiving appetizer: Set these out before dinner and watch what happens. My uncle stood by the tray last year like he was guarding it.
Uses up leftover stuffing: Got stuffing in your fridge from yesterday? You’re basically halfway done. No waste.
Crunchy outside, soft middle: That contrast is what hooks people. You bite through the crispy part and it’s warm and buttery inside.
Kids go nuts for them: Anything bite-sized and my kids are in. My son dips his in gravy, my daughter eats them plain.
Works as a side or appetizer: I’ve done both. Nobody questioned it either time.

Ingredient Notes and Substitutions

Mostly pantry stuff. Couple things worth knowing before you get going though.

Cornbread stuffing mix: This gives you that crumbly base with a little sweetness to it. Can’t find cornbread? Regular seasoned stuffing works. My friend Jackie always uses the herb-flavored kind and hers come out good too.
Low-carb bread: Toast it first, chop it small. You could do regular white bread or even sourdough if low carb isn’t your thing. I just like what it does for the texture.
Unsalted butter: A whole cup. Yeah. That’s what makes them taste the way they do so don’t you dare skimp. If all you have is salted, use it, just ease up on the kosher salt.
Chicken broth: One can. Part goes in the mix and then you pour the rest over the stuffing balls halfway through baking. Veggie broth works fine if you’re keeping it meatless.
Ground sage and dried thyme: These two carry the flavor. Don’t skip them. My mom used to say sage is what makes stuffing smell like Thanksgiving and ya know something? She wasn’t wrong about that.

Tips for Success

I’ve made these enough times to know where things go sideways. Few things.

Don’t make them too big: Golf ball size. That’s it. Bigger ones won’t cook through evenly, and the middles stay mushy. Made baseball-sized ones at Christmas as an experiment. Bad idea.
Toast your bread first: Skip this, and your stuffing bites will be soggy. Dry bread absorbs the broth and egg without falling apart.
Easy on the squeeze: You want them holding together on the pan but not packed so dense they turn into rocks. Like a snowball you don’t actually want to hurt somebody with.
That second broth pour matters: Sounds weird pouring liquid on something you want crispy. But it steams the inside while the oven does its thing on the outside. Don’t skip it.

Storage and Reheating

Put the container with a lid into the fridge. Holiday food like this is good for about 4 days.

Reheat in the oven, 375, about 10 minutes. The oven is the move here because the microwave turns them soft all the way through and you lose that whole crunch situation. My husband microwaves his anyway. I’ve given up on that battle.

Freezing works too. Lay them on a tray first, so they don’t all freeze together in a clump, then move them to a bag. Good up to 2 months. From frozen, oven at 375, 15 to 20 minutes, and you’re set.

Serving Suggestions

Gravy for dipping. That’s honestly the whole point of these.

Cranberry sauce works too, the whole berry kind, not the jelly stuff. My mom puts out both, and people go back and forth. You could also set them next to turkey and mashed potatoes and green beans, the full spread. Or just eat them standing at the counter at 10pm, which is what I do half the time.

FAQs

Can I make these with leftover stuffing?

That’s how I got started making them in the first place. If your leftover stuffing is already seasoned and still moist, skip most the ingredient list. Add an egg to hold it all together, roll into balls, and bake. You might not need that broth pour either if your stuffing’s wet enough on its own.

Can I make stuffing bites ahead of time?

Yep. Roll them, put them on the sheet, cover the whole tray in plastic wrap, and fridge it. Bake them the next day. I do this every Thanksgiving morning, so I’m not running around the kitchen like a crazy person later.

What if my stuffing balls fall apart?

Needs more moisture. Splash of broth or another egg. The mix should hold together when you squeeze it in your hand. If it crumbles, too dry.

Are these good for a party?

I gotta tell ya, these are probably the best Thanksgiving appetizer I’ve ever brought anywhere. People grab them like popcorn. Toothpicks and a couple dipping sauces on the side. That’s all you need.

Notes

This whole thing started because of my neighbor Pam, day after Thanksgiving 2023. She came over with a plate of these, and I could not stop eating them. Called her that night for the recipe, and she laughed at me. Said “it’s just stuffing rolled into balls, honey.”

She was right. But that broth pour trick was hers, and I think that’s the thing that makes them special. I owe that woman a plate of something one of these days.